"Send me one more man." Every owner hears it.
"Hey boss, we need more men on our crew." Some weeks you hear it from every job.
What one more man costs
Example: on a 5-person crew, one more man is 20% more man-hours before anyone asks why.
That's not a small decision. Do it on a few crews for a few weeks and it shows up in the job cost report as a labor overrun nobody can explain.
Sometimes he's needed
Sometimes the crew really needs him. The pour is bigger than planned. The site is tight. The finish spec is harder than it looked.
Sometimes the day was set up wrong, the material was late or the goal was never clear. Adding a man won't fix any of those. It just makes the problem more expensive.
When I ran my concrete company, I couldn't tell the difference from the office. Without a number, neither can you.
Let the number answer
Measure units per man-hour every day and the question answers itself.
If the crew is on goal, the extra hand goes where the score needs him. If they're behind, you find out why before you add cost. Maybe it's one more man. Maybe it's a better plan for tomorrow morning.
Let the whole crew see it
Here's what surprised me. When every person on the crew sees the day's goal and score, not only the foreman, the crew starts sizing itself.
Everyone understands something important: crew size matters. Too few hands and the goal slips away. Too many and good people end up waiting on each other instead of building.
So the crew adjusts, on their own.
When their crew is on pace, a worker raises his hand: "You've got this. I'll go help the east job." When they're falling behind, they welcome help from the next crew over, because they know that's how the whole team wins.
Nobody has to order it. It's their choice and their pride.
Share the help
Here's what that looks like when it's working:
- Every employee sees the daily goal and score
- Crews understand how their size affects the goal
- Workers volunteer to help where they're needed
- Help comes back when they're the ones behind
- Everyone thinks like an owner, every day
This isn't about cutting people. It's about trusting them. When people can see the numbers, they make good decisions, and they feel like part of one team, not a headcount on a schedule.
Give them a reason
Measured labor savings fund incentives. That gives the crew a reason to size itself right, so you avoid unnecessary extra manpower.
When the savings get shared, the crew that sends a man to help the east job isn't giving something up. They're helping the company win, and they share in it. Read how self-funding incentives work.
The question to ask first
Next time a foreman asks for one more man, ask one question first: where is the crew against the goal? If he knows the answer, you can decide together in a minute.
If he doesn't know, that's the first thing to fix. A foreman who can't say where his crew stands against the goal is asking for more men without the facts. Give him the number every day, and the request gets better, or goes away on its own.
Measure first, then decide
We've seen this for over 30 years, since 1993. Give the whole crew the score, and they'll show you what it really takes.
Staff for the work, not for the guess. Measure first. Then decide. See how daily production by cost code puts the number in front of every crew.


