PayCrew Blog

When Your Estimator Retires, Keep the Rates

Veteran construction estimator reviewing production rates and history charts

When your best estimator retires, how much of your production history leaves with him?

In a lot of companies, most of it. And nobody notices until the first few bids after he's gone.

The rates live in one head

In a lot of companies, the real rates live in one person's head.

He knows what a crew can do on a tight site in January. He knows that one general contractor's jobs always run slow, and that a pump pour goes faster than one off the chute. He knows which numbers in the estimating system are wrong and adjusts them by feel.

Nobody else does. It was never written down, because it never had to be. He was always there.

What happens when he leaves

When that estimator retires, the company keeps the software and loses the judgment.

The next estimator starts from the book rates. Some bids come in too high and you lose work you should have won. Some come in too low and the crews get a goal they can't hit. The field blames the estimate. The office blames the field. It takes years to rebuild what walked out the door.

Every company has a version of this. It might be the estimator, a long-time superintendent or the owner.

Daily measuring puts it in the record

Daily measuring puts that knowledge in the record.

Every day the crews enter units and man-hours, the history builds. Yards placed per man-hour on a slab. Square feet finished. Linear feet formed. Job after job, crew after crew, season after season.

With attributes, the history also captures what made the work different: the method, the conditions, the location. So the record knows the difference between a January pour on a tight site and an open slab in May. Read more about that in cost codes and attributes.

Now the rates aren't in one person's head. They're in the company.

Start the next estimate from earned rates

Our DeltaDrift add-on measures the days already done, so the next estimate starts from the rates the crews earned, not from memory.

It also shows whether an estimate can be met before a crew is asked to meet it. That protects the crew from an impossible goal, and it protects the company from a bid that only looked good on paper.

Keep the judgment too

None of this replaces a good estimator. Judgment still matters. Someone still has to look at a set of drawings and see what's going to be hard.

But judgment works best on top of real numbers. A new estimator with ten years of measured history can learn fast. A veteran with that history can stop guessing at the parts he doesn't remember.

Let him check the history

Here's a good use of your veteran estimator's last few years. Have him review the measured history against what he remembers. Where they match, you have confidence. Where they don't, he can explain why, and that explanation is worth writing down too.

Don't wait for the retirement party

Most companies start worrying about this when the retirement date is set. By then, there's only a few months to capture what took decades to learn. Start measuring now, while he's still there to tell you which numbers to trust and which ones need a second look.

Plan for it now

If you have an estimator who's ten years from retirement, now is the time to start. Every day you measure is another day of history he can check, correct and pass on.

Keep your estimator's judgment. Just don't let it be the only copy.

See how daily production by cost code builds that history.

More from the blog

Carpenter carefully marking a board with a square and pencil

Where Heart Meets Craft on Your Crews

You can't order behavior to change. Here's how daily production measuring connects the care your crew already has to the work they do.